In UN Peacebuilding, Local Ownership Takes Backseat

Global Governance journalLocal ownership of peacebuilding activities makes sense in theory, but is rarely put into practice in UN peace operations. This was the main message of a talk I gave recently at the Permanent Mission of Norway to the United Nations, which was organized by the journal Global Governance.

The -11C temps and lingering snow from the day’s previous storm thankfully did not deter the group of UN ambassadors, members of the UN secretariat, university professors, and think tank staff who came to listen and to share their experiences with the theory and the practice of peacebuilding.

UN peacebuilding Western SaharaAfter my opening remarks, those present explored the ambiguity surrounding local ownership in peace operations. It was noted that post-conflict contexts are not “blank slates,” but rather contexts where a variety of actors hold immense amounts of power and this complicates the question of who is really in charge of the efforts to bring countries emerging from war to a stable peace. These ambiguities need to be managed constructively, but the UN often lacks the capacity to channel them into political strategies. Three initiatives are, however, helping to increase the focus of these questions: the 15-year High Level Review of Resolution 1325 on Women, Peace, and Security, the High-Level Independent Panel on Peace Operations, and the 10-year Review of Peacebuilding.

Norwegian Ambassador Geir O. Pedersen then mediated a lively discussion. One ambassador spoke about the very good intentions of UN staff who sign up to work in peacebuilding, but suggested that more training was necessary for staff to understand the local context to work more effectively with the local communities. He also noted the importance of balancing the need to work with locals alongside the fight against impunity for those who might have been involved in atrocities during conflict—linking local ownership to the debate on peace vs. justice.

UN peacebuilding in DRCAnother ambassador echoed the call for the need to understand local cultures and to be sensitive towards local views. It was remarked that while there is a need for the consent and cooperation of host countries and a need to consider their priorities, the state has disintegrated to such an extent in some places that we cannot speak of local ownership at the national level.

Speaking on behalf of a country that has hosted UN peacebuilding activities, another ambassador remarked that there are limits to the amount of “social engineering” the international community can undertake. While the success of certain peacebuilding efforts is indisputable, he stressed that self-determination must be preserved and it is unrealistic to expect that developing countries can be politically or socially transformed overnight.

Representatives of the International Peace Institute noted that the focus on local ownership in recent years has meant that civil society has played a larger role in peacebuilding processes. Several participants agreed that UN staff often do not have the capacity, time, and guidance for addressing these questions. While UN staff come with ambitious and principled goals for peacebuilding, they often also bring with them assumptions about the contexts in which they are working and are required to focus on short-term results rather that the longer-term challenges of ownership and inclusion.

UN peacebuilding in DRC GomaunIt was gratifying to see my academic work resound with those on the front line of UN policymaking, in particular as the UN undergoes major reviews of its peace operations and of its peacebuilding architecture. As a scholar as well as a former UN staff member, I am deeply committed to bringing together the academic and policymaking communities in order to share knowledge and perspectives, and I believe firmly that academic research should be relevant and useful for policymakers. It was therefore valuable to see not only that the participants were broadly in agreement regarding the challenges and contradictions surrounding the discourse and implementation of local ownership that my research outlines, but also the possible ways forward for the UN.

Many thanks to Ambassador Geir O. Pederson and the staff of the Permanent Mission of Norway for hosting this event. Thanks as well to the One Earth Future Foundation and ACUNS for organizing this talk as part of the new Global Governance discussion series, which convenes  actors working on current problems from a variety of perspectives. My paper, “Local Ownership and UN Peacebuilding: Discourse vs. Operationalization,” will be published in Global Governance in May, 2015.

  • the important of using evidence to make decisions in peacebuilding

    How Do We Get to an Earth Without War?

    OEF's Executive Director and Chief Operating Office, Jon Bellish talks about OEF's commitment to Relentless Empiricism as core to its belief in and support of iterative problem-solving and careful, analytical design. He discusses how OEF relies on evidence to cut through complexities in order to solve concrete problems at the root of armed conflict, and bring new, collaborative forms of governance into being in its place. Read More
  • Stable Seas program is leaving One Earth Future

    Setting Sail: OEF’s Stable Seas Program Reaches New Milestone

    After three years of programmatic incubation, OEF’s Stable Seas program has reached a new milestone. Because of the team’s success demonstrating how accessible information on the relationships between maritime security and on-shore violence can shape the preparedness of government leaders, on May 1st the program’s work is being taken on by a new independent entity being formed by a consortium of partners anchored by the United Nations Office on Drugs & Crime. Read More
  • The Difficulty of Peacebuilding in Syria

    Peacebuilding Requires a Coordinated Effort

    OEF’s goal is ultimately the elimination of war. In order to achieve this admittedly lofty goal, we need to have a working theory of the causes of war and how we can help to disrupt them. Fortunately, there is a large body of research in “peace science” and, more broadly, political science. In developing our theory, our challenge wasn’t having too little information - it was coming up with a way of analyzing all of the research out there and developing a theory of war useful to our work. Read More
  • Open Nuclear Network - Engagement Network Members

    ONN Announces Engagement Network Members

    Open Nuclear Network (ONN) is excited to introduce the members of its Engagement Network (EN) to a broader audience. During the past year, ONN has worked to establish close working relationships with esteemed former senior officials and experts from China, Japan, Russia, South Korea and the United States, all committed to working together with ONN on the focused mission of nuclear risk reduction on the Korean Peninsula and in the broader Northeast Asia region. Read More
  • women's history month March women peacebuilders perspectives

    Perspectives on Peace | Celebrating Women’s History Month

    It is well documented, today, that women’s empowerment and gender equality are critical to achieving peace and stability around the world. The full and meaningful leadership, empowerment, and protection of women is essential to resolving deadly conflict and building stable, prosperous, and just post-conflict societies. We celebrate and support women and their male allies around the world who are working together to make that a reality. Happy Women’s History Month! Read More
  • Somali investments European Union

    Shuraako Partners With the EU to Boost the Somali Private Sector Through Access to Finance

    On February 2, 2021, the European Union launched 3 new projects in support of Somalia’s private sector. One of the projects will contribute 5.5M€ to the Nordic Horn of Africa Opportunities Fund (the ‘Nordic Fund’) which is an impact fund targeting Somali small and medium sized enterprises. This brings the total funds that Shuraako manages (under the Nordic Fund) to $24 million. Read More